************************************************************* THE TANACH STUDY CENTER [http://www.tanach.org] In Memory of Rabbi Abraham Leibtag Shiurim in Chumash & Navi by Menachem Leibtag ************************************************************* Yehoshua - chapters 13->19 The 'nachala' section - From Gilgal to Shiloh Chapters 13-19 in Sefer Yehoshua are rarely studied, and for a very good reason - their minute detail of geographic borders and lists of cities from thousands of years ago, doesn't appear to carry much relevance. In the following shiur, we won’t make those details any more exciting - however, we will find significance in the manner of their presentation; that may also help us appreciate events taking place in Israel today! INTRODUCTION Once Yehoshua’s united army had defeated the major armies of Eretz Canaan, as described in chapters six thru twelve; it was now time for each tribe to 'finish the job' and settle their assigned territories. As we will see, some of the tribes immediately rose to this challenge, and did an excellent job of settling their "nachala", while the other tribes were far less successful. Before we begin our discussion of 'what went wrong', we begin our shiur with an overview of what transpires in these seven chapters. KIBUSH vs. NACHALA As we explained in our previous shiurim, Sefer Yehoshua neatly divides into two distinct sections: 1) Chapters 1-12: KIBUSH - Military conquest of the Land 2) Chapters 13-22: NACHALA - The inheritance of each tribe. Therefore, chapter 13 begins the "nachala" section, which will focus on how each tribe settled (or didn't settle) its assigned portion. The internal order of this section is very logical. Chapter 13 begins with the conquests by GAD, REUVEN, and HALF OF MENASHE, for the simple reason that they were first to inherit their land, even before Bnei Yisrael had crossed the Jordan (see Bamidbar Chapter 32). Chapters 14 and 15 describe how the tribe of YEHUDAH, encouraged by their leader Kalev, took the initiative and quickly completed their conquest of the entire area that became known as the Judean Hills. Two entire chapters in Sefer Yehoshua are dedicated to the details of that conquest and the names of the settlements that they established. Similarly, Chapters 16 and 17 describe how the tribes of EFRAIM & MENASHE undertook a serious effort to conquer their inheritance in the hills of Samaria, even though they were not as successful as Yehudah. In contrast to these five tribes who actively took the initiative, Sefer Yehoshua dedicates much less detail to the remaining seven tribes who were far less successful. Chapter 18 describes how Yehoshua gathers these seven tribes in Shiloh to encourage them to make a greater effort (see 18:1-5), and the remainder of that chapter and chapter 19 describe the borders that these remaining seven tribes were expected to inherit One could suggest that via this manner of presentation, Sefer Yehoshua is teaching us an important lesson, congruent with the overall theme of the book - that God helped those (tribes) who helped themselves! Said differently, even though God had promised to assist Bnei Yisrael in their conquest of the land, His intention was for each tribe to take an initiative to be worthy of divine assistance (see 1:3). Therefore, those tribes that remained passive remained with minimal portions. WHAT WENT WRONG At first glance, it is rather hard to fathom why the tribes would be so reluctant to settle the land that Yehoshua's joint army had just conquered. However, when one considers the realities of their situation - their behavior is quite easy to understand. Let's consider how Bnei Yisrael have been living for the past forty years in the desert. For most of the adult population, the only existence they have known has been a rather passive 'camp-style' environment, with the Mishkan at the center of their camp. During those forty years, God had provided for their food and water (and clothing / see Devarim 8:1-8). Most of the time, they remained in the same campsite for many years (e.g. see Devarim 1:46). Recently, the entire nation had crossed the Jordan River and set up camp in the Jordan Valley in a site called Gilgal. Even though there was no more 'manna', water was now provided by the Jordan River, and grain grew in the bountiful fields of Jordan valley. [See Yehoshua 5:10-12.] Every once in a while, the men went out to battle - to conquer the hills and valleys of the land of Canaan; but for the families living in Gilgal, daily life was really not that much different than it had been in the desert for the last forty years. WHY LEAVE GILGAL? Now that the conquest was complete, Yehoshua encouraged all the tribes to leave Gilgal, i.e. to take their women and children on a trek into the mountain land - to establish new settlements. However, to do so was 'easier said than done'. Anyone who has visited the Jordan Valley readily understands why. Picture yourself living in this relatively secure environment, with no immediate danger to your livelihood. To the west, you see a massive mountain range, beyond which your elders inform you is a 'land flowing with milk & honey'. But you also know that there are many other nations who once lived in that land (and apparently many still remained, or quickly returned). So, are you going to leave the neighbors and friends you've grown up and lived with for the last forty years, and travel out into the unknown - or you going to 'pass up the opportunity' and stay put in Gilgal? The same choice that most people would make today, was the same choice that most of the people made back then. The majority of the nation stayed in Gilgal. This also explains why the first wave of successful military campaigns did not necessarily lead to a complete conquest. If settlement did not commence as soon as those battles were won, the opportunity of total conquest was lost. Those battles (described in chapters ten and eleven) explain why Bnei Yisrael were no longer under the threat of immediate destruction from the joint armies of the nations of Canaan; but they do not describe the complete settlement of the land that was captured. That remained a very difficult challenge. The tribe of Judah was different, but of course their "nachala" was not very far away from Gilgal, and Yehoshua's military campaign in the Judean hills was quite complete. However, it is quite easy to understand why the inheritance of the rest of the country was off to such a poor start. The people were 'only human'. THE 'SHILO PLAN' This background can help us appreciate the transition that takes place in Yehoshua chapter 18. Note how chapter 18 opens by relating almost 'parenthetically' how Yehoshua transferred the Mishkan from Gilgal to the city of Shilo, before it begins its primary topic of describing the "nachalot" of the remaining seven tribes. However, that small detail, as we shall now explain, relates directly to the primary theme of the entire chapter. To ascertain why Yehoshua had gathered the entire nation at Shilo is obvious from the opening statement of his speech: "And Yehoshua said to Bnei Yisrael - ‘ad matai atem MITRAPIM (for how long will you remain LAZY), and not conquer the land that God has given you...’" (18:3) Note how harshly Yehoshua rebukes these seven tribes who had yet to take their nachala (see 18:3-7). Clearly, Yehoshua distinguishes between the five tribes (Reuven, Gad, Yehuda, Efraim, and Menashe) who had taken initiative and conquered their territories and the seven remaining tribes who had failed to do so (Binyamin, Yisachar, Zevulun, Dan, Naftali, Asher, and Shimon). He gathers them to encourage these remaining tribes to take a more active role towards securing their nachalot. Immediately after this rebuke, Yehoshua divides the remaining land among these seven tribes, assigning each a specific portion that they needed to survey and conquer (see 18:4-10). However, this does not explain why Yehoshua moved the Mishkan to SHILO specifically at this time. We will now attempt to explain how these two events - moving the Mishkan and rebuking the tribes - are thematically connected. A NEW INCENTIVE As we explained above, from the time that Bnei Yisrael had crossed the Jordan, Gilgal had served as the national center. Not only was the Mishkan immediately set up in Gilgal, but that site also continued to serve as the 'national center' during the seven years of Yehoshua’s conquest (see 4:19; 5:9-10; 9:6; and 10:9,43). However, according to Sefer Devarim, it is very clear that Gilgal was never meant to remain the permanent resting place of the Mishkan. Upon the completion of their conquest of the land, Bnei Yisrael were supposed to establish a more permanent site for the BET HA’MIKDASH - referred to in Chumash as "ha’makom asher yivchar Hashem l’shaken shmo sham" (see Devarim 12:4-12). It appears that Yehoshua’s conquest was not yet considered complete enough to warrant the building of this permanent MIKDASH. So why did Yehoshua move the Mishkan to Shilo? If the time was not yet ripe to move it to its permanent destination, why didn’t he simply leave it in Gilgal? Based on our above discussion, we can suggest the following explanation: Yehoshua faced a dilemma. On the one hand, the time had certainly not come for building the permanent Mikdash - for the "nachala" was far from complete. Paradoxically, though, it may very well be that one of the primary reasons WHY the nachala was not complete was BECAUSE the Mishkan remained in Gilgal! Let’s explain: Recall that for the past forty some years Bnei Yisrael had dwelled in the desert in tents, in a camp formation surrounding the Mishkan. After the primary conquest (KIBUSH) was complete and there was no longer an immediate danger of war from the nations of Canaan, the tribes were left with two options: (1) to LEAVE Gilgal, and establish new settlements in their various assigned nachalot, or, (2) to STAY in Gilgal and continue the life style that they had grown accustomed to during the past forty years in the desert. As we have explained, five tribes took the initiative and established their nachalot (option #1), however the remaining seven tribes opted to stay in Gilgal (option #2). This, as we have explained, was not what they were supposed to do. Therefore, to encourage these remaining tribes to settle their nachalot, Yehoshua devised the 'Shilo Plan'. By moving the Mishkan to Shilo, Yehoshua hoped to accomplish three things: (a) to disperse the temporary campsite in Gilgal by taking away its primary attraction - the Mishkan. (b) to establish Shilo, a town located at the center of the densely forested mountain range of Har Ephraim, as the new national center. This would encourage the settlement of this difficult area by the tribe of Ephraim (see 17:14-18) and strengthen Bnei Yisrael’s overall position in the mountain range of Eretz Canaan. (c) to encourage the other tribes to leave Gilgal and establish their own nachalot. This explains why Yehoshua not only moved the Mishkan to Shilo specifically at this time, but also why he gathered together all the tribes and demanded that they write down their respective borders and commence with the conquest of those areas (see once again 18:1-10). These were not two unrelated events, but rather two components of one operation. To a certain extent, the 'Shilo Plan' was quite successful. Shilo established itself as the new national center, replacing Gilgal; and the remaining tribes began to inherit their own nachalot. However, as we will later learn in the beginning of Sefer Shoftim, this second phase of the conquest remained rather incomplete. Furthermore, from the minimal mention of Shilo in Sefer Shoftim, it appears that Shilo never really developed as the powerful religious center that Yehoshua had hoped it would become. [Note its lone mention and context in 19:18 and 21:19-23, as well as how corrupt the site had become by I Shmuel Chapters 1-4.] Moving the center to Shilo was a bold move, reflecting wise leadership; nonetheless - it remains unclear if the damage created by placing the Mishkan in a new center so far away from daily access, was worth the price that Bnei Yisrael paid in their attraction to other gods, which immediately became a problem as soon as each tribe moved to their new areas, and encountered new cultures. (See Sefer Shoftim chapters one and two.) In our next shiur, we will continue our study with a discussion of the special significance of the nachala of the tribe of Binyamin, as described in chapter 18.